The Dearly Beloved Book Review – Cara Wall’s Tender Story of Love, Loss, and Spiritual Doubt

– A Quiet Story of Faith, Grief, and Connection

• 
  

A Quiet Invitation

Cara Wall’s The Dearly Beloved is not a fast read—and why should it be? This novel invites you to sit quietly in a church pew in 1950s New York City and listen to the lives of four very different people trying to love, to believe, and to make peace with their pain.

The novel traces the intertwining journeys of two couples whose lives are shaped by faith, doubt, marriage, grief, and unexpected connection. Wall’s writing is spare but rich, gentle but deeply emotional.

Why We Have Written the Dearly Beloved Book Review

At Porch Light Pages, we’ve been reflecting on self-care and the quiet courage it takes to sit with hard feelings. This novel lives in that very space. It doesn’t rush or try to tie things up neatly.

Instead, it honors what’s unresolved.

Grief. Spiritual confusion. Marital disconnection. Even joy. These rise slowly through the story like parishioners filing into a sanctuary. And what struck me most is how these characters care for themselves and one another—not by fixing, but by being present.

A Line That Lingers

“She had grown up believing that the only way to be good was to be good to others. It had never occurred to her that being good to herself mattered.”

Whether you're someone who gives a lot, feels things deeply, or carries a quiet faith—or questions it—this line might stay with you too.

The story gently asks: What does it mean to care well for others and ourselves?

And how do we hold space for both belief and doubt in the same room?

Who This Book Is For?

This story is for the deep feelers and the quiet thinkers.

If you’ve ever wrestled with your beliefs, loved someone through silence, or tried to find steadiness in a world that keeps shifting—The Dearly Beloved will meet you there.

It’s especially meaningful for therapists, writers, clergy, caregivers, or anyone navigating relationships, grief, or questions of purpose.

But truly, it’s a book for all of us—those who carry others and those learning to carry themselves.

Final Thoughts

In a noisy world, The Dearly Beloved is a soft, sacred kind of novel. One that doesn’t demand your attention, but gently keeps it. It reminds us that grace often shows up in ordinary moments and quiet rooms.

A thoughtful, tender pick for your next read.

I hope you enjoy this read as much as I did.

Lori

Porch Light Pages

For the ones carrying heavy, quiet things:

Not every ache needs to be solved today. Some feelings just want to be witnessed. You don’t have to name them all, and you don’t have to make them pretty. You only have to sit beside them long enough to say, "You’re allowed to be here."

Let that be enough for now. Let that be the beginning of gentleness.